Can’t Contracting Be Relational?; Comment on “Alignment in the Hospital-Physician Relationship: A Qualitative Multiple Case Study of Medical Specialist Enterprises in the Netherlands”

Document Type : Commentary

Author

Faculty of Medicine, Health and Life Science, Swansea University, Swansea, UK

Abstract

Ubels and van Raaij provide a valuable account of the operation of novel hospital/medical specialist enterprise (MSE) contracts in a Dutch healthcare system shaped by market reform. However, their analytical distinction between the separate domains of contractual and relational governance frames the contractual domain more narrowly than does the relational contract theory widely deployed in socio-legal studies. The authors’ conclusion that contract plays little or no part in governing relations between hospitals and MSEs leads them to underplay a wider realm of contractual practices that develop in the shadow of the written contract. Apparent non-use of contracts in favour of shared planning, compromise and extra-legal solutions only takes the form it does because of the potential application of the available legal framework. Larger qualitative field studies involving a more extensive combination of interviews and observations may be needed to gain fuller insights into the relational dimensions of the contracting process. 

Keywords

References

  1. Ubels S, van Raaij EM. Alignment in the Hospital-Physician Relationship: A Qualitative Multiple Case Study of Medical Specialist Enterprises in the Netherlands. Int J Health Policy Manag. 2023;12:6917. doi:10.34172/ijhpm.2022.6917
  2. Campbell D. The Relational Theory of Contract: Selected Works of Ian Macneil. London, UK: Sweet & Maxwell; 2001.
  3. Zenger TR, Lazzarini SG, Poppo L. Informal and formal organization in new institutional economics. In: Ingram P, Silverman BS, eds. The New Institutionalism in Strategic Management. Bingley, UK: Emerald Group Publishing Limited; 2000:277-305. doi:1016/s0742-3322(02)19009-7
  4. Scott RE. The promise and the peril of relational contract theory. In: Braucher J, Kidwell J, Whitford WC, eds. Revisiting the Contracts Scholarship of Stewart Macaulay: On the Empirical and the Lyrical. Oxford, UK: Hart Publishing; 2013:105-139.
  5. Scott R. The new institutionalism in contract scholarship. Jotwell: The Journal of Things We Like (Lots). 2017:1-3. https://scholarship.law.columbia.edu/faculty_scholarship/3225/.
  6. Campbell D, Picciotto S. Exploring the interaction between law and economics: the limits of formalism. Leg Stud. 1998;18(3):249-278. doi:1111/j.1748-121X.1998.tb00017.x
  7. Braucher J, Kidwell J, Whitford WC. Revisiting the Contracts Scholarship of Stewart Macaulay: On the Empirical and the Lyrical. Oxford, UK: Hart Publishing; 2013.
  8. Campbell D. Contractual Relations: A Contribution to the Critique of the Classical Law of Contract. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press; 2022. doi:1093/oso/9780198855156.001.0001
  9. Whitford WC. Ian Macneil's contribution to contracts scholarship. Wis L Rev. 1985:545-560. https://api.law.wisc.edu/repository-pdf/uwlaw-library-repository-omekav3/original/90f23ce311660d32030d58ab6d320a51ff681d0e.pdf.
  10. Macneil IR. Contracts: Exchange Transactions and Relations. 2nd ed. Mineola: Foundation Press; 1978.
  11. Frydlinger D, Vitasek K, Bergman J, Cummins T. Contracting in the New Economy: Using Relational Contracts to Boost Trust and Collaboration in Strategic Business Relationships. London, UK: Palgrave Macmillan; 2021. doi:1007/978-3-030-65099-5
  12. Macneil IR. Contracts: adjustment of long-term economic relations under classical, neoclassical, and relational contract law. Northwest Univ Law Rev. 1977;72:854-905.
  13. Macaulay S. Non-contractual relations in business: a preliminary study. ASR. 1963;28:55-67.
  14. Campbell D. What do we mean by the non-use of contract? In: Braucher J, Kidwell J, Whitford WC, eds. Revisiting the Contracts Scholarship of Stewart Macaulay: On the Empirical and the Lyrical. Oxford, UK: Hart Publishing; 2013:159-190.
  15. Sagy T. What's so private about private ordering? Law Soc Rev. 2011;45(4):923-954. doi:1111/j.1540-5893.2011.00461.x
  16. Hughes D, Allen P, Doheny S, Petsoulas C, Roberts J, Vincent-Jones P. NHS contracting in England and Wales changing contexts and relationships. Final Report. NIHR Service Delivery and Organisation Programme. London, UK: Queen’s Printer and Controller of HMSO; 2011. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/301576773_NHS_contracts_in_England_and_Wales_changing_contexts_and_relationships_Final_report.

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 15 June 2024
  • Revise Date: 07 October 2024
  • Accept Date: 12 October 2024
  • First Publish Date: 13 October 2024

Share

How to cite

Statistics